Heritage Western Cape Final Comment February 2020 Heritage Western Cape Final Comment
OCA Appeal to the Water Tribunal June & July 2021 Appeal Against the Water Use License granted to Liesbeek Leisure Property Trust by the Department of Water and Sanitation
Basic Assessment Report April 2020 The Redevelopment of the River Club, Observatory, Cape Town Final Basic Assessment Report Prepared for Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust by SRK Consultants
Hydrology Report March 2018 Investigation into the impact of the proposed redevelopment of the River Club on flooding and flood abatement in the Salt River Catchment Prepared for Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust by Aurecon
City of Cape Town’s Environmental Management Department Appeal September 2020 appeal against the Environmental Authorisation which as highlighted in (Jens Horber's Daily Maverick article) lists 12 grounds for appeal including: that “the decision does not align with relevant national and provincial legislation, provincial and city policy and spatial plans, and the Environmental Management Framework approved by DEA&DP”. The appeal highlighted procedural and due diligence issues on the part of DEA&DP, and noted that the decision did not adequately take into account the city’s previous comments on the environmental reports submitted by the developer. noting that “the decision does not give due consideration to climate change impacts and resilience, and fails to apply the precautionary principle” and proposal to turn the original river course into a stormwater swale, which is essentially a grassed, open stormwater ditch.
“The Ecological Corridor referred to… is a misrepresentation of facts. Once the habitat of the Liesbeek River has been destroyed through infilling, there will be no movement of animals from there anymore. The paths across the River Club site they used to traverse, will be empty and unused. The need for the ecological corridor arises from the significance of the habitat of the Liesbeek River, and the need to maintain the ecological linkages across the River Club site, for frogs, otters and birds which move to and from the Liesbeek River and the Raapenberg wetlands, noted by various specialists and members of the public. With no life left in the Liesbeek River, the raison d’etre for the ecological corridor falls away.”
Biodiversity Impact Assessment December 2019 which states that the site provides a habitat to important bird species and may provide breeding areas to endangered Western leopard toads Prepared for Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust by Freshwater Consulting cc